Judges in Hillsborough County, FL

The judicial directory for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit in Hillsborough County, FL, can be found at https://www.fljud13.org/JudicialDirectory.aspx. The directory contains the judge’s name, phone number, courtroom number, office number, and judicial assistant’s name.

Each judge has a profile page that contains additional contact information, the judge’s procedures/preferences, forms, schedules, orders, related links, and announcements.

If available, the court’s link for Zoom virtual hearings can be found on the profile page. Most judges have eliminated the option of appearing via Zoom. Make sure you have written permission from the clerk’s office or your criminal defense attorney before failing to appear in person in court.

At the Sammis Law Firm, we appear in court each time, but often waive our client’s appearance to many of the initial court dates with permission from the court after filing a waiver of appearance. Of course, for any evidentiary motion hearings or trial date, our client must appear in person and arrive to court early.

Judicial Assignments in Hillsborough County, FL

Administrative Order A-2025-060 (Judicial Assignments) became effective January 1, 2026. The judicial assignments for judges that handled criminal cases and cases related to criminal accusations are listed below:

Judicial Assignments
DIVISION LTR JUDGE’S NAME OFFICE CRT RM
CIRCUIT CRIMINAL
Circuit Criminal A TWINE THOMAS, Barbara 230 Annex 18
Circuit Criminal B FERNANDEZ, Kimberly K. 540 S. Annex 55S
Circuit Criminal C PALERMO, Thomas N. 615 Annex 62
Circuit Criminal D GREEN, G. Gregory 228 Annex 16
Circuit Criminal E TIBBALS, Wesley D. 616 Annex 61
Circuit Criminal F ALVAREZ, Lindsay M. 506 S. Annex 54S
Circuit Criminal G NAZARETIAN, Nick 132 Annex 19
Circuit Criminal I RICE, Elizabeth G. 227 Annex 15
POST CONVICTION RELIEF
Post Conviction Relief J *SISCO, Michelle D. 102 Annex 10
VIOLATION OF PROBATION
Violation of Probation K LEFLER, Lawrence M. 226 Annex 11
MENTAL HEALTH
Mental Health M SCIONTI, Michael J. 515 Annex 52A
VETERANS TREATMENT COURT
Veterans Treatment Court V *SCIONTI, Michael J. 515 Annex 52A
TRIAL DIVISION
Trial Division 1 *SISCO, Michelle D. 102 Annex 10
Trial Division 2 GOUDIE, Lyann 516 Annex 51A
Trial Division 3 FUSON, Robin F. 229 Annex 14
DRUG COURT
CJT: Adult Drug Treatment Court W *SCIONTI, Michael J. 515 Annex 52A
MARCHMAN ACT
Marchman Act Z POMPONIO, Denise A. 426 Annex 30
FIRST APPEARANCE/EMERGENCY
First Appearance/Emergency O MURPHY, J. Logan 233 Annex 17
PROTECTIVE INJUNCTIONS
Protective Injunctions G *PERRONE, Frances M. 309 Edgecomb 302
Protective Injunctions H COSTELLO, Jessica G. 313 Edgecomb 303
Protective Injunctions K BLACK, Melissa C. 316 Edgecomb 306
JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
Juvenile Delinquency A POMPONIO, Denise A. 426 Annex 40
Juvenile Delinquency F *BRENNAN, Kim 462 Annex 43
JUVENILE MENTAL HEALTH
Juvenile Mental Health B *BRENNAN, Kim 462 Annex 43
JUVENILE DRUG COURT
Juvenile Drug Court E POMPONIO, Denise A. 426 Annex 30
EAST CIRCUIT
Protective Injunctions q WILLIAMS, Michael S. Plant City
COUNTY CRIMINAL
County Criminal A SMITH, Matthew A. 213 Annex 24
County Criminal B TAYLOR, Margaret 330 Annex 31
County Criminal C VALKENBURG, Miriam 617 Annex 12
County Criminal D ALLEN, Lisa A. 334 Annex 32
County Criminal E SCOTT, Monique M. 344 Annex 33
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
Domestic Violence F *PERRONE, Frances M. 309 Edgecomb 30
FIRST APPEARANCE
First Appearance O MURPHY, J. Logan 233 Annex 17
CIVIL TRAFFIC
Civil Traffic M CUELLAR-STILO, Mary Lou 235 Annex 21
NON-CRIMINAL NON-TRAFFIC
Non-Criminal Non-Traffic T CUELLAR-STILO, Mary Lou 235 Annex 21
EAST COUNTY CRIMINAL
East County Criminal X GRINER, Jeremy R. 2021 Plant City 1

County Court Judges in Hillsborough County, FL

Except for domestic violence criminal offenses, the clerk assigns all misdemeanor offenses and criminal traffic offenses to a county criminal division according to the first letter of the defendant’s last name. This rule applies to all cases going to the courthouse in Tampa, FL, because cases assigned to the Plant City Courthouse use a different procedure.

For non-domestic violence cases based in Tampa, FL, if the notice to appear, criminal report affidavit, or information is filed, then the clerk will assign the case according to the following alphabetical distribution:

  • Division “A” with The Honorable Matthew A. Smith
  • Division “B” with The Honorable Margaret R. Taylor
  • Division “C” with The Honorable Miriam Valkenburg
  • Division “D” with The Honorable Lisa A. Allen
  • Division “E” with The Honorable Monique M. Scott

The Honorable Frances M. Perrone, who is assigned to County Criminal Domestic Violence Division “F.” All domestic violence cases go to this division.

If you are charged with a felony, your case will be assigned to a felony judge in Circuit Court in Hillsborough County, FL, the criminal division.


This article was last updated on Tuesday, January 27, 2026.